Redefining Leadership Equality
Creating an inclusive path to leadership for all genders by challenging biases and reshaping expectations.
Why Do We Still Default to Male Leaders? A Call to Change How We Think About Leadership
Imagine you’re hiring for a leadership role. You have two equally qualified candidates—one male, one female. Who gets the job? Statistically, many of us, whether consciously or not, will lean towards the male candidate. But why? And how can we challenge and change this deeply ingrained bias?
Even women, who are often their own best advocates, may hesitate when considering leadership roles. Studies show that women themselves sometimes doubt their fit for leadership, perhaps seeing traditional expectations as misaligned with their skills and strengths. This mindset reveals an uncomfortable truth: before we can expect society to change how it views leadership, we must change how we think about it.
The Heidi vs. Howard Experiment: Bias in Action
To understand the “double bind” women face, let’s look back to 2003, when Professor Frank Flynn at Columbia Business School conducted a fascinating experiment. He presented his class with a case study on Heidi Roizen, a successful venture capitalist, then gave half of the students a version with Heidi’s name changed to Howard. Both versions were identical in every detail except the name. Both groups saw their subject as competent—but while Howard was seen as a strong potential colleague, Heidi was labeled as too aggressive and self-interested.
This case study highlighted a powerful bias: society tends to associate assertive, decisive traits with men and nurturing, supportive traits with women. When women demonstrate traditionally “masculine” qualities, they’re often seen as competent but unlikeable. Meanwhile, a man displaying the same traits is viewed positively, even celebrated as a “natural leader.” And this bias isn’t limited to gender; anyone who doesn’t fit the traditional mold—such as non-binary colleagues—can find themselves penalized simply for challenging stereotypes.
Crafting Inclusive Job Postings to Speak to All Genders
If we want to open the door to more diverse leaders, we must start with the basics, like how we write job postings. Often, these postings use language that unintentionally reinforces male-centric leadership ideals. To attract a broader range of candidates, here are a few tips:
Balance Assertive and Collaborative LanguageInstead of “must dominate and lead decisively,” try “must inspire, collaborate, and guide a team toward achieving shared goals.” This language welcomes varied leadership styles.
Highlight Key Qualities Without Gender BiasOpt for phrases like “must have a strong vision and the ability to implement strategic goals” rather than “must aggressively pursue targets and dominate the market.” The former speaks to capability and determination without implying a narrow, forceful style of leadership.
Include Flexibility and Empathy as StrengthsEmpathy, adaptability, and a focus on collaboration are often overlooked in job postings but are key to effective leadership. Including them as strengths helps attract a more diverse and inclusive range of applicants.
Changing Our Own Mindset First
Before we can inspire inclusivity in others, we need to look inward and ask ourselves some tough questions: Am I truly inclusive, or do I default to traditional biases in high-stakes decisions? Do I inadvertently disregard qualities I don’t fully understand? Am I open to change?
Becoming more inclusive starts with challenging our own assumptions, especially in how we respond to different leadership styles. And by doing so, we become allies in reshaping what leadership looks like, broadening it to include diverse strengths rather than a one-size-fits-all model.
Ways to Be an Advocate for Equality in Leadership
Support Female and Non-Binary Colleagues Out LoudEndorse their ideas in meetings, recommend them for leadership roles, and openly recognize their contributions. These small gestures can have a huge impact, helping to shift others’ perceptions in a positive direction.
Stand Strong in Your Own LeadershipIf you’re a woman or non-binary person in a leadership role, don’t feel pressured to water down your confidence. By embracing your style, you set a standard that leadership can look many different ways.
Consider Flexible Business Models Like Direct SellingTraditional corporate structures often make it hard for women and non-binary individuals to rise without facing bias. Business models like direct selling or entrepreneurial platforms, on the other hand, allow for autonomy, community support, and leadership growth outside of corporate constraints.
Mentor and Educate for the FutureIf you’re in a leadership role, mentor younger female and non-binary employees. Help them build confidence, learn the skills they need, and see that it’s okay to bring their authentic selves to work. This one-on-one guidance creates a ripple effect, empowering future leaders to redefine expectations.
The Bigger Picture: A Future Where All Genders Can Lead
The journey to equality in leadership is about creating workplaces that value diverse perspectives and talents, regardless of gender. Non-binary colleagues and others who don’t fit traditional norms face biases similar to those faced by women. True inclusivity means building a space where everyone is valued not just for fitting in but for standing out.
So, Why Do We Still Stick to Archaic Expectations?
Even as we strive to be more open-minded, many of us have internalized outdated expectations of what a “leader” should be. For women, in particular, unlearning these norms can take time. But as more women and non-binary people embrace their own leadership styles, they inspire others to do the same. And change is happening, slowly but surely.
The first step toward a future where everyone can lead authentically is to look within. We can’t always change our biases overnight, but by examining them and choosing to act differently, we set a powerful example. So let’s start asking not who “fits” a role, but how the role can fit anyone with the right qualifications and passion.
Want to dive deeper into the Heidi/Howard experiment? Check out Professor Flynn’s work through Columbia Business School’s archives or a presentation he held. It’s a simple, powerful reminder of how stereotypes persist—and why it’s up to us to change the narrative.
And remember: building an inclusive workplace is about more than being “nice.” It’s about creating a space where everyone can lead, no squeezing into outdated molds required.
Comments